Sealy Posturepedic vs Simmons Beautyrest

Sealy and Simmons are two of the major companies in the mattress industry. Both have recognizable names and outstanding reputation. So, which one does make better products? In the following article, we will see the comparisons between their top lines, Sealy Posturepedic vs Simmons Beautyrest. The most highlighted features of Sealy Posturepedic are the reduced motion transfer and the wide range of firmness levels and availability. On the other hand, Simmons Beautyrest is known for the superior comfort and support.

Sealy Posturepedic – Overview

To choose between Sealy Posturepedic vs Simmons Beautyrest, let us first see the overview of this mattress. Sealy was founded in 1881, and it has grown to be one of the leading mattress brands in the United States with at least 25 plants to produce its box springs and mattresses. Sealy was bought by Tempurpedic in 2012, but the two companies still operate independently. Sealy is best known for its quality design and innovation, including the use of pocketed springs and continuous heavy-gauge wire springs.

Sealy Posturepedic, as indicated by the name, is a line of mattresses which focuses on support. The mattresses are designed to be able to provide extra support to the sleeper’s body, along with a 10% – 20% wider sleeping area and a firm edge. Sealy Posturepedic is further divided into three series, which are Classic, Gel, and Hybrid.

The Classic series offers mattresses with lumbar support and spring coils made of titanium alloy. The combination ensures good support, bounciness, and great durability. The prices start from $599. Meanwhile, the Gel series starts from $899 and features mattresses with a gel memory foam layer, optimized to minimize heat while providing conformed support. It will conform very comfortably to your body and provide support on the back and joints. Finally, the Hybrid series starts from $1299; this model features greater amounts of gel memory foam and poly foam over pocketed springs for enhanced support and greatly reduced motion transfer.

Sealy Posturepedic – Pros

When choosing between Sealy Posturepedic vs Simmons Beautyrest, the first advantage of Sealy Posturepedic that people usually mention is the wide range of available firmness options. Each mattress model in the Sealy Posturepedic line is available in several firmness levels, so you can choose the one that suits you best. If you really like the feel of “sleeping on the cloud”, then you may consider getting a soft mattress. However, if you have back pain and need extra support, choosing a firmer and more supportive model is generally more recommended.

The pocketed coils used in Sealy Posturepedic mattresses are very durable and supportive. Due to the pocketed design, they have reduced motion transfer – you will not get woken up every night by your partner’s movements. The high coil counts ensure enhanced support, and this is very important for heavier people.

The memory foam models are surprisingly great. Unlike traditional memory foam mattresses which tend to emit odor and maintain heat, Sealy Posturepedic’s memory foam does not release much odor. It does not get too hot, although it still maintains heat to a degree. It is useful throughout the year.

Sealy Posturepedic – Cons

Although Sealy Postureoedic is quite durable, it is not the most durable mattress in the world. It may start to sag after about six years of usage. At this point, it will still be usable, but you will start to notice reduced performance in terms of support and bounce. In most cases, a Sealy Posturepedic mattress can be used for about 10 years before needing a replacement, but you can certainly have it longer with proper care.

Simmons Beautyrest – Overview

Just like Sealy, Simmons is a brand that has been around for decades. The brand is currently owned by a group which also owns the competitor brand, Serta. In terms of sales, Simmons is one of the five biggest bed companies in the United States. Simmons mainly focuses on hybrid and innerspring beds.

Simmons Beautyrest is the brand’s flagship. It centers on innerspring mattresses, but there is also the Comforpedic memory foam series. The mattresses in this line vary by coil count and density, and there are also models with additional layers such as pillowtop and gel memory foam. There are also several different sizes available.

Simmons Beautyrest – Pros

The first advantage that is mentioned when people choose between Sealy Posturepedic vs Simmons Beautyrest is the support. Simmons Beautyrest is known to provide excellent support, so it is suitable for people with back or joint pain. Many users say that Simmons Beautyrest is able to help reduce and even eliminate their pain problems within a few years.

Simmons Beautyrest also has low motion transfer. So, it is great for couples. If you need a large mattress where you can sleep with your partner, Simmons Beautyrest makes a great choice. The low motion transfer ensures that your sleep will not get disturbed by your partner’s movements. In addition, Simmons Beautyrest is backed by a great warranty which goes for 20 – 25 years, depending on the model.

Simmons Beautyrest – Cons

Some models in the Simmons Beautyrest line, especially those that utilize memory foam, are said to have some noise and odor issues. This is not good. The noise may be annoying at night, when you are trying to sleep, whereas the odor is bad for health.

Just like many innerspring mattresses, Simmons Beautyrest also has a problem with durability. According to some users, it may start to sag and have reduced support after three or four years. Fortunately, there is the warranty to handle defective products. With proper care, though, Simmons Beautyrest can last for more than ten years.

Finally, Simmons Beautyrest is quite expensive. Most of the models in this line come with prices above a thousand bucks. So, this option is only suitable if you have a good sum of budget.

Serta iComfortPerfect Sleeper
- Memory foam mattresses- Gel memory foam with fewer layers
- Comes with a specific firmness level- Relatively more supportive
- 10 to 15 years of warranty- Coils and edge support


Sealy Posturepedic and Simmons Beautyrest have different pros and cons. Sealy Posturepedic is generally more recommended because of the more affordable prices and the wide range of firmness options. However, if you don’t mind spending extra money for the enhanced support and pain relief, Simmons Beautyrest is a good choice.

Leave a Reply