Simmons Beautyrest vs Serta Perfect Sleeper

Are you confused in choosing between Simmons Beautyrest vs Serta Perfect Sleeper? Both of these two mattresses are coil mattresses. You should consider getting a coil mattress if you are looking for a mattress that is bouncy and supportive, suitable for a wide range of sleepers including heavy sleepers and for night activities. However, choosing the right mattress model is indeed never an easy task. That’s why, in the following article, we will help you choose the best mattress can give you the most comfortable and enjoyable sleep. Continue reading!

Simmons Beautyrest: Design and Construction

Simmons Beautyrest has become one large part of the industry for quite a long time. The brand Simmons, after all, has always been focused in producing luxury mattresses, and the company has been successful in the direction. But let’s see if the luxury mattress is really worth the money. By the way, we have compared Beautyrest vs Saatva before, so don’t forget to check it out!

There are actually many different versions of Simmons Beautyrest that may vary by the firmness level and price. However, let’s focus the comparison by choosing the most affordable model of the line-up, which is Simmons Beautyrest Black Desiree. You can say that this model is the closest to Serta Perfect Sleeper.

Simmons Beautyrest Black Desiree is quite a complex mattress. It has a total thickness of 13.5”, and it is built from multiple layers of memory foam and coils. The topmost layer is made of 2.25” memory foam. This layer is optimized to create the initial softness and pressure relief so that the sleeper can rest comfortably.

The second layer is made of 1.0” gel memory foam. The placement is for a reason. By putting the gel memory foam layer right under the top layer, it can pull away heat from the sleeping surface, ensuring that the sleeper will always feel cool during the sleep. Meanwhile, the third layer is made of 0.5” memory foam and also designed to help heat dissipation.

Finally, the fourth and the lowermost layer is 9.75” thick. This layer contains a lot of pocketed coils, designed to provide the deep compression support needed especially by heavy sleepers. This layer is also important because the coils are responsive and bouncy, making the mattress comfortable and suitable for amorous activities. Meanwhile, surrounding the perimeter is the edge support layer. It consists of 3” encased-edge support foam. It is meant to enhance the durability and usability of the edges of the mattress.

Serta Perfect Sleeper: Design and Construction

Unlike Simmons which focuses in producing luxury mattresses, Serta is a more flexible and versatile brand. It has various models available on multiple price points, from the low-end segment to the high-end luxury class. Serta Perfect Sleeper is one of the most well-received models, praised for the superior construction quality and great comfort.

Serta Perfect Sleeper has been designed to solve five most common sleep problems, which are pressure points, insufficient back support, unbalanced sleeping temperature, motion transfer, and roll-off/sagging. This mattress is made using the liquid-enhanced Cool Twist Gel Memory Foam to provide enhanced pressure relief and balanced sleeping temperature. The top layer feels very comfortable. It can contour the body very well, and is quite responsive.

Just like Simmons Beautyrest, Serta Perfect Sleeper features a layer of coils. These coils are surrounded by the BestEdge Foam Encasement to prevent roll-off and sagging. So, you can sleep on the edge of the mattress without worrying about getting rolled down in the middle of your sleep. All the coils are individually wrapped so that they can provide localized support points and eliminate motion transfer from coil to coil. As a result, the mattress has very low motion transfer, and you won’t be woken up by your partner’s movements.


Now, let’s compare the covers of Simmons Beautyrest vs Serta Perfect Sleeper. The cover of Simmons Beautyrest is very nice and highly breathable. This is because the cover is made from a blend of 70% Tencel and 30% polyester. The cover is strong yet soft and breathable. You will not feel as if you are sleeping on a heat trap. It also appears aesthetically pleasing, as the quilted design looks beautiful and elegant.

On the other hand, the cover of Serta Perfect Sleeper is quite simpler. It also has a quilted design. But the squared pattern surrounding the mattress’s sides doesn’t look nice or stylish. Still, the cover is quite comfortable and breathable.


Now, let’s see the comparisons between Simmons Beautyrest vs Serta Perfect Sleeper in terms of performance. Even though Simmons Beautyrest is sometimes described as a plush mattress, you may want to take it with a grain of salt. The term ‘plush’ often refers to something that is soft or medium-soft. However, Simmons Beautyrest is actually more of a medium-firm mattress.

It has decent support. It is a great choice for a variety of sleepers. Back, side, and stomach sleepers can use it without a problem. The mattress is also able to provide consistent spinal alignment in various positions. Finally, note that the mattress’s memory foam layers can give sharp and precise contouring.

On the other hand, Serta Perfect Sleeper is primarily praised for the construction quality and coils. This mattress is durable. It is available in three different firmness levels, which are firm, plush, and pillow top. So, you can choose the one that suits your needs best.

Serta Perfect Sleeper is a very cool mattress. For sure, you will not get any hotness problem. Compared to Simmons Beautyrest, Serta Perfect Sleeper tends to be more supportive.

Trial and Warranty

Finally, it is also important to take a look at the warranties of Simmons Beautyrest vs Serta Perfect Sleeper. Interestingly, both Simmons Beautyrest and Serta Perfect Sleeper mattresses are each given a 10-year warranty from their respective manufacturers. But Simmons Beautyrest provides a 100-night trial period without refund allowance, whereas Serta Perfect Sleeper provides a 45-night trial period with refund allowance.

Simmons BeautyrestSerta Perfect Sleeper
- Gel memory foam with multiple layers of different types of foam- Gel memory foam with fewer layers
- Coils and edge support- Coils and edge support
- More pronounced contouring- Relatively more supportive
- More elegant appearance- More conventional look


If you prefer a coil mattress with more pronounced contouring, Simmons Beautyrest is the way to go. It is very comfortable, and the contouring can relieve pressure points. However, if you prefer a more supportive mattress, Serta Perfect Sleeper should be your choice. This mattress is designed to solve all the five most common sleep problems, so this mattress is very comfortable as well.

Leave a Reply