In this article, we will see the comparisons between two popular modern mattresses, Tuft And Needle vs Brooklyn Bedding. Both companies are known for selling affordable mattresses online. The more direct marketing and distribution allow them to keep budget-friendly price tags. Still, there are some price differences between the two brands, and the mattresses do have distinctive characteristics.
Continue reading below to find out more about:
- The construction and materials of each mattress
- How firm and supportive each mattress is
- The motion transfer on Tuft And Needle vs Brooklyn Bedding
- The sinkage and contouring of each mattress
- The shipping, trial period, and warranty
- Which mattress that is generally more recommended for the money
Tuft And Needle: Construction
Tuft And Needle was among the earliest companies to join the online mattress craze back then, around 2012. The company wanted to improve the consumers’s mattress shopping experience by offering mattresses are with more transparent costs. Nowadays, Tuft And Needle still stands out in the competition because their prices are quite lower than the competitors.
Tuft And Needle only produces a single model, which is designed to serve all consumers regardless of the sleeping preferences. This is indeed convenient, but how could Tuft And Needle be so confident that their mattress suits most if not all sleepers?
In order to create a mattress with a wide appeal, Tuft And Needle breaks down the qualities into three categories, which are cooling performance, support, and pressure relief. The founders created prototypes over and over again while tweaking the construction and testing the iterations. Finally, they believe that they have created a mattress which is enjoyable for all people.
It is interesting that the Tuft And Needle mattress only consists of two foam layers to create a general feel that is appealing to a wide range of sleepers. However, the comfort layer (which uses the company’s proprietary foam) is the one with the most influence on the feel of the mattress.
- The base layer, which is immediately under the comfort layer, has a thickness of 7 inches. It is made from poly foam that has a density of 1.8 lbs. It is responsible for being the foundational support, ensuring the mattress’s durability and structural integrity.
- The comfort layer has a thickness of 3 inches. It uses Tuft And Needle’s proprietary foam, which is a kind of poly foam with a density of 2.9 lbs. It is responsible for creating the general feel and pressure relief. It has pretty quick response and good bounce, so you will not feel stuck in it.
- The cover is made from a stretchy blend of Polyester and Tactel. The thin design is very nice, as it allows smooth air flow through the mattress and good temperature regulation. Tactel is often used for clothing items to substitute cotton; Tactel dries a lot more quickly than cotton.
Take a look : Restonic vs Sealy.
Brooklyn Bedding: Construction
Brooklyn Bedding is an American mattress company that is known for producing quality hybrid models, which combine foam and the pocketed coil technology to give the best balance between pressure relief and support. Unlike Tuft And Needle, which only produces a single model, Brooklyn Bedding has produced several models, such as Signature, Aurora, and Bowery. However, in this article, we will focus on the flagship model, which is Brooklyn Bedding Signature.
Tuft And Needle vs Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are very different. While Tuft And Needle goes with a relatively simple construction, Brooklyn Bedding is the opposite. It comes with a more complex construction with several layer sand materials.
- The base layer has a thickness of 6 inches, and contains pocketed coils. This is actually the new version; the old one uses high-density poly foam as the base. This new version with pocketed coils allows enhanced bounce. The increased bounce makes it easier for the sleeper to get up from the bed. In addition, the space between the coils allows increased air flow, so that the mattress will feel cooler.
- The transition layer has a thickness of 2 inches. It is built from a firmer variant of the company’s proprietary Titan Flex Foam. It ensures a smooth transition from the soft top layer to the supportive base below.
- The comfort layer has a thickness of 2 inches. It is built from a softer variant of the Titan Flex Foam that is combined with the company’s proprietary Titanium Gel. The latex-like character of Titan Flex Foam allows great bounce and response, whereas the Titanium Gel keeps things cool for the sleeper. The combination of these two special materials is very nice.
- The cover is made from a blend of polyester and cotton. The combination is comfortable on the skin, and is breathable. It also has quilted foam, which enhances the softness and pressure relief. The quilted foam allows the sleeper to start sinking into the mattress almost immediately.
Firmness and Pressure Relief
Now, we will see how Tuft And Needle vs Brooklyn Bedding compare against each other in terms of firmness and pressure relief. Although they both have foam top layers, they do have slightly different characteristics.
Tuft And Needle has good softness and quick response to pressure. When you lie on it, you can immediately feel how the mattress sinks and adapts to pressure spots. And although the pressure relief is very good, Tuft And Needle still does a decent job if you sleep on your stomach by supporting the hips. However, if you are quite heavy, you will push deeper into the mattress and feel the firm base layer of the mattress.
The fact that Tuft And Needle does not have any transition layer is very important. Without a transition layer, a heavy sleeper will meet an abrupt change from the soft top to the firm base. In general, Tuft And Needle does manage to create a general feel that is suitable for most people. The firmness level falls in the medium range, with heavy sleepers giving higher firmness ratings and light sleepers giving slightly lower firmness ratings.
Brooklyn Bedding has a similar soft feel on the surface. The quilted foam creates softness, and the comfort layer allows some sinkage and good pressure relief. However, as you press deeper, you will start to feel the rebound coming from the buoyant Titan Flex Foam as well as the pocketed coil system.
Brooklyn Bedding is actually available in three different firmness options, which are soft, medium, and firm. We take the medium level for this comparison, which is generally compatible with most people.
Brooklyn Bedding has received mixed ratings from different sleepers, but they generally fall in the medium range. Most people say that Brooklyn Bedding is quite softer than Tuft And Needle. This is because the mattress has a transition layer, so the sleeper will not come into contact with the firm base directly. Even so, if you are particularly heavy, you will still feel good deep compression support from the pocketed coil system in the base.
If you are planning to share your mattress with a partner, motion isolation becomes a very important factor to consider. Without good motion isolation, any movement or vibration from the other side of the bed will be transferred to your side. As the effect, your partner’s movement may disrupt your sleep.
Tuft And Needle has good motion isolation, thanks to the all-foam construction. Several tests have shown that this mattress is able to attenuate vibrations very well. Slight movement will not be felt on the other side of the bed. A heavy impact will be noticeable at first, but it is quickly reduced to nonexistence.
On the other hand, Brooklyn Bedding has pretty good motion isolation. The pocketed design of the coils helps to minimize motion transfer. However, compared to Tuft And Needle, the motion transfer is still more significant. The coils create some bounce and tend to keep vibration. Fortunately, slight movement on the other side of the bed will not be too noticeable. But a heavy impact will be very noticeable, and the vibration will be felt for a little while.
Sinkage and Edge Support
In general, both Tuft And Needle vs Brooklyn Bedding have prominent sinkage and contouring.This is not necessarily good or bad, as different people have different preferences. Some people prefer more sinkage due to the contouring, whereas some others prefer less sinkage because they can’t stand the enveloping feel.
The overall feel of Tuft And Needle is quite balanced across the body. Although the sinkage and contouring are good, an average sleeper will not sink too deeply into the mattress. The mattress has more sinkage on the lighter body parts, but less sinkage on the heavier body parts.
If you love good contouring, you will love Tuft And Needle. The comfort layer does an excellent job in this aspect. There are no significant pressure spots. In the test, an 8-lb medicine ball gets 2.5 inches of sinkage, a 50-lb steel ball gets 4 inches of sinkage, and a 100-lb medicine ball gets 6 inches of sinkage.
The edge support of Tuft And Needle is also very good. This is quite surprising, as foam mattresses often have terrible edge support. Sleeping on the edge of Tuft And Needle feels just as supportive as on the center. The contouring is also similarly good on the edge, just like on the center.
On the other hand, Brooklyn Bedding has more noticeable sinkage. This is because of the quilted foam on the cover and the soft comfort layer. A sleeper will sink deeper on Brooklyn Bedding than on Tuft And Needle. In other words, Brooklyn Bedding makes a great choice for those who love sinkage and contouring, but a poor choice for those who prefer to stay on the top.
In the test, the lighter body parts do not sink too deeply into the mattress. However, the heavier body parts do sink deeper. A 10-lb steel ball only experiences 2 inches of sinkage, but a 50-lb medicine ball gets 5 inches of sinkage and a 100-lb medicine ball gets 6.5 inches of sinkage.
In contrast with Tuft And Needle, Brooklyn Bedding does have more noticeable sinkage on the edge. But saying the edge support is bad is a serious understatement. You may feel that the foam gets more compressed when you lie on the edge, but it still feels very supportive and secure. You will not get rolled down and fall from the mattress. Sitting on the edge of the bed is also easy and comfortable.
Shipping, Trial, Warranty
Both Tuft And Needle vs Brooklyn Bedding provide free shipping across the United States. Their mattresses are all compressed and packaged in easy-to-carry boxes. So, getting either of the two mattresses into your home should be easy and effortless.
Each of the two companies also provides a 10-year warranty for each mattress. The warranty timeframe is good, although not particularly impressive. However, both companies are known to have good customer support, and they both serve warranty claims properly according to the requirements and policies.
The two companies do have different trial periods. Knowing the trial period is very important, because you need to try the mattress first to see whether the mattress suits you or not. While still in the trial period, it is possible for you to return the mattress and get a refund.
On Tuft And Needle, the trial period goes for 100 nights, starting from the purchase date. This is already good, albeit shorter than Brooklyn Bedding’s trial period. Within the trial period, you can already get a good idea about the character of the mattress. Keep in mind that Tuft And Needle is available at a slightly lower pricepoint than Brooklyn Bedding, and the price difference can be a worthy plus point to atone for the shorter trial period.
However, Brooklyn Bedding provides a longer trial period of 120 days. This is better, although not a major plus point over Tuft And Needle. Keep in mind that, while still in the trial period, it is also possible for you to return the mattress if you find a defect in the material quality or craftsmanship.
Brooklyn Bedding vs Tuft And Needle
|Brooklyn Bedding||Tuft And Needle|
|- Three layers: 6” base, 2” transition layer, 2” comfort layer||- Two foam layers: 7” base layer and 3” comfort layer|
|- The base uses pocketed coils||- All foam construction|
|- Cover is soft, made from polyester and cotton||- Cover is more breathable with polyester and Tactel|
|- Lower firmness and more sinkage||- Higher firmness and less sinkage|
|- Slightly lower edge support||- Better edge support|
|- 120-day trial period||- 100-day trial period|
|- More expensive||- More affordable|